There’s a scary email that’s been making the rounds for some time warning folks that the “National Association of Realtors” is “all over” a 3.8% sales tax that was part of the Obama Health Care Bill… the retiring generation is getting screwed, etc. etc. It doesn’t mention that the sky might be falling too. This tax has been called a transfer tax and a sales tax, but it’s actually neither. Unfortunately some REALTORS have jumped on the scare bandwagon because they are afraid this have a big negative impact on the real estate business.
Without getting all political, I will say that I’m not a fan of the Health Care Bill, but this sort of criticism of it is unfounded. I’ve been referring folks to the Snopes Urban Myth site for years on general principles… and would suggest the same for this except there’s an even better source: the National Association of Realtors has addressed this with some facts. There’s short blog post and video that explains the tax in simple language. Again, I’m not saying that I’m supporting the tax, but it is no where near what this email claims and since this email just isn’t going away, I decided to post about it here.
For starters, if (and there’s a big if) it were to apply, it would only apply to individuals earning more than $200,000 per year and couples with a joint income of greater than $250,000. Additionally, it is not going to apply to the sales price of a home–it MIGHT apply to a portion of investment income. In other words, it MIGHT apply to a portion of the capital gain acheived. It is NOT a real estate transfer tax and it is NOT a sales tax on real estate.
Again, I’m not saying it’s a good law or a good tax–but criticizing it with scare tactics, exaggeration, and just plain wrong information accomplishes nothing. NAR (National Association of Realtors) has actually produced a free brochure outlining several different scenarios.
If you receive the scary email, don’t forward it. Objecting to bills, laws, and taxes needs to be done with diligence and solid facts–not scare tactics. The tax is scheduled to take effect in 2013 so it would be wise to get educated.
By the way, the information I’m referring to was actually written and posted in November 2010–which just goes to show you the power and durability of fear. People are quick to forward the scare… most won’t forward a link to the facts!






Walter is a licensed real estate broker, but not yours unless we agree to it! (In Maine, real estate law requires a written agreement.) Therefore, the content of this site is intended for informational and educational purposes and is not meant to serve as advice -- professional or otherwise. If you have property currently listed for sale or you are contracted with an agency for real estate services, this is not intended as a solicitation of those services.
Walter is an instructor associated with the Piscataquis Valley Adult Education Cooperative and Arthur Gary School of Real Estate

